Who Watches “The Watcher”?
August 12th, 2010What do you do when the person responsible for overseeing our elections fails miserably in following the very laws put into place that assure fair elections? In other words: who watches “The Watcher”?
In political campaigning great efforts have been made, and systems put into place, to assure a level playing field when it comes to the rules candidates play by. Much like the processes of “discovery” and “disclosure” in our court system which assure no surprises that might unfairly influence a jury, the rules for candidates and their committees also assures that we the voters are not unfairly influenced in our vote by the hiding of significant information.
One of the authorities that candidates report to locally is the Office of the County Clerk. In addition to the County Clerk’s Office, candidates for state offices and some county offices must also report the details of their campaigns to the statewide authority: the Missouri Ethics Commission (MEC). Since it wouldn’t be appropriate for the sitting County Clerk to have regulatory oversight over their own (and their opponents’) campaigns, candidates running for the position of County Clerk are obviously required to file with the MEC….
Obviously, that is, unless you are the County Clerk in Buchanan County. Despite the fact that both of her Democratic primary election opponents and her Republican general election opponent managed to properly file multiple reports with the Missouri Ethics Commission, Kelley Stahlin, our Buchanan County Clerk of 5 months who claims to have many years of election “experience” somehow felt that those rules didn’t apply to her. From the time she first began accepting campaign contributions on January 20, until she finally got around to filing her reports with the MEC (on July 20th, just 2 weeks before the August primary), 6 full months had passed without her providing legally required campaign details. That’s half a year!
Ethics laws have been established that set deadlines for filing information publicly. They establish requirements for disclosing not only who is responsible for accepting, disbursing, and maintaining the records of a candidate’s campaign funds, but who has contributed and how much. Every other candidate for County Clerk managed to follow the rules, but somehow the person responsible for making sure every other local candidate followed those rules didn’t follow the rules!
That’s why when it comes to County Clerk candidates, the Missouri Ethics Commission (MEC) is the watcher that watches “The Watcher”. And in the case of the Buchanan County Clerk and candidate, Kelley Stahlin, it’s a good thing they do!
In the 6 months that passed since she started accepting contributions, the following reports were never provided through the Missouri Ethics Commission for review by her opposing candidates as is required by state statutes:
A) She failed to properly form a campaign committee and report it within 20 days to the MEC despite accepting over $2,000 from a single contributor in February. By the time she did finally file the required report, it was only 14 days before the election. State law requires committees be formed more than 30 days before the election (that would have been by July 4). In addition, once the information about her campaign was finally filed on July 20th, it was backdated to the nonspecific date of “February 2010”.
B) She improperly reported loans she had received by failing to correctly indicate who was responsible for repaying loans totaling $4,000 that were made to her campaign. (The person who gave the loan was also responsible for paying it back? To themself?)
C) She failed to file the first quarter contributions and expenditures report that was due on April 15th. It was filed on July 20th, 96 days (more than 3 months!) late. We now know she had accepted campaign contributions totaling over $2,700.
D) She failed to file the second quarter contributions and expenditures report that was due on July 15th. It was also filed on July 20th, 5 days late, when we eventually found out she had accepted an additional $3,400 in contributions.
Ethics laws were put into place to ensure a fair process. As the current County Clerk, Stahlin has no excuse for failing to follow the laws that she is responsible for upholding. It was 6 months into her campaign before she got around to it. Maybe the $1,000+ in fines that she faces (which are proscribed for filing late at $10 per day) will be a wake up call for her. Despite being our local election authority, she is either ignorant of the laws everyone else managed to follow, or as “The Watcher” she thinks she is above those laws. But don’t worry, it WILL be a wake up call for us, the voters, in November… since ultimately WE CHOOSE “The Watcher”.


