Close, But No Cigar
March 7th, 2012The debate on a city wide ban on smoking in closed air facilities is being fueled by a barrage of press releases from activist group Clean Air St. Joe, but in the opinion of MCV-PAC, their plans to infringe on the rights of business owners should go up in smoke.
Recently, Clean Air St. Joe spokeswoman Sara Summers said in a St. Joseph Post article that a new ordinance banning smoking indoors doesn’t prevent smokers from smoking, it’s a matter of public safety, and therefore is not an issue of big brother smothering individuals.
Summers’ comment is only a half truth. She is correct that it does not dictate that individuals can’t smoke, but it does dictate how businesses can operate as they see fit. It prevents a business, namely restaurants, from setting their own policy based upon the demands of the clientele they serve.
Let’s be honest, if a local pub thought it was more profitable to go smoke free, they would. Individuals have the right to patronize or boycott a business based upon the atmosphere the ownership, NOT THE GOVERNMENT, dictate. By speaking with their wallets, they can affect the change they desire, not by adding another intrusive government mandate.
While the press has thrown softball questions to Clean Air St. Joe regarding this issue, MCV-PAC is anxious for to hear the answers to the tough questions. Let’s start with this one: Will the St. Joe Frontier Casino be exempt from this ordinance? If so, why will they have a free pass and not our small businesses?


